Home > Facebook & Instagram > Account Issues and Questions

Account Scammer, should I out him? (58)


03-13-2012 07:28 PM #1 navuud (Member)
Account Scammer, should I out him?

So I've gotten scammed for nearly $8k by an account seller, someone noteworthy in AM (who everyone knows/should know).

Should I out him here? Might help the community from dealing with him in the future, and would ruin his rep for sure--which he clearly doesn't care about if he's willing to scam for ~$8k.

His name is Brandon Clark.


03-13-2012 07:36 PM #2 mraffiliate (Member)

Yes out his ass. Sorry to hear about that experience. Everyones worst nightmare


03-13-2012 07:43 PM #3 shoent (Member)

def. out his ass man. scammers deserve to be outed shit


03-13-2012 07:44 PM #4 navuud (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by mraffiliate View Post
Yes out his ass. Sorry to hear about that experience. Everyones worst nightmare
Indeed. Funny thing is the 1st deal we had for a lower level account ($2.5k) went through. Then when he sells me a high level account ($5k), I pay him, he takes 2 weeks before he says all of his accounts got hammered. So he eventually says he'll bump my original account to $10k (+$7.5k). I agree. He gets it bumped to $5k, then promises it'll get to $10k.

Then boom, last night he decides to change the PW, and claims FB changed it because the account was traced to multiple IP's...(LOL clearly lying). Sends me a bogus e-mail.

Clearly he decides to take the account back when he finds out that FB isn't handing em out like they were before.


03-13-2012 07:59 PM #5 nusolutionz (Veteran Member)

definitely out him if you're 100% sure that he is trying to scam you!


03-13-2012 08:11 PM #6 navuud (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by nusolutionz View Post
definitely out him if you're 100% sure that he is trying to scam you!
Waiting for him to clarify the entire situation. But it's very obvious he's lying, and he's lying more to explain the situation...which baffles me. I'll see if he pays me first. If not, he'll get exposed everywhere.


03-13-2012 08:24 PM #7 lng (Member)

Hopefully he's not on this forum.


03-13-2012 08:42 PM #8 joshogle (Member)

Just be careful that if you do call someone a scammer for sure that they really have done wrong.

Give it a few days from when the deal was supposed to go down and if he doesn't do as he promised, warn us all.

EDIT: and if he chooses to help you only after you've said something to him re: telling everyone on this forum, tell us his name anyway.


03-13-2012 08:51 PM #9 rich (Member)

ooo i wanna know who it is :P


03-13-2012 09:55 PM #10 inversion (Member)

Just state the facts.


03-13-2012 10:16 PM #11 mgrunin (Member)

Ouch. I guess some folks really are low on money.


03-13-2012 10:33 PM #12 ibanez (Member)

definitely give us his name, its seems like he is not able to deliver and (maybe) hopes that you will go away.


03-13-2012 10:38 PM #13 navuud (Member)

I'm hearing that he's scammed multiple other people, does shady shit. Really inclined to out him soon.


03-13-2012 10:39 PM #14 ibanez (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by navuud View Post
I'm hearing that he's scammed multiple other people, does shady shit. Really inclined to out him soon.
dont keep us waiting much longer


03-13-2012 10:52 PM #15 chiefsurf (Member)

Just be sure man... I say out him if you are 100% sure he is scamming you.


03-13-2012 11:19 PM #16 hd2010 (Member)

out his name to stop the nonsense


03-13-2012 11:19 PM #17 blackberry (Member)

STM Drama, love this stuff


03-14-2012 12:55 AM #18 jimcrim (Member)

Where's my popcorn, this shit is too good. Sorry to hear that you're getting jerked around by this guy, but high drama on the STM is where its at tonight. I say out him if he doesn't make it right.


03-14-2012 02:15 AM #19 extremesg (Member)

Spilllllllll it!!!


03-14-2012 02:39 AM #20 nitroman (Member)


03-14-2012 03:21 AM #21 maynzie (Moderator)

Hahahaha ^


03-14-2012 03:26 AM #22 wyffgoal (Member)

^ maynzie, I know if there is a like button you would have liked it already just like me.. haha


03-14-2012 05:51 AM #23 palmtree (Member)

popcorns getting cold.. cmon


03-14-2012 07:03 AM #24 kenny_powers (Member)

we are being trolled!


03-14-2012 11:18 AM #25 ppchound (Member)

Yeah. Either shit or get off the pot.


03-14-2012 12:00 PM #26 navuud (Member)

I have to wait and make sure, I can't taint someone's reputation unless I'm absolutely sure. Though at this point I don't think I'll get my money back or the equivalent in accounts.


03-14-2012 12:19 PM #27 dario (Member)

how many accounts does he have to deliver ?


03-14-2012 12:24 PM #28 navuud (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by dario View Post
how many accounts does he have to deliver ?
He has to deliver $7.5k in accounts.


03-14-2012 01:57 PM #29 miked3 (Member)


03-14-2012 02:43 PM #30 extremesg (Member)


03-16-2012 04:04 PM #31 lng (Member)

Since the mods are friends with him and have talked to him about the situation, it should be easy to get him in here to clear everything up.


03-16-2012 04:28 PM #32 dubbsy (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by extremesg View Post
Instead of everyone speculating (apart from OP), get Brendon's ass in here Mods - then kill his account here after 'justice has been served'. If Brendon doesn't want to defend himself in here, .... then I guess that speaks for itself!

Simple right?
^^ probably the best solution for the sake of continuing business... We could all say, speculate, or comment... but unless both parties are present to discuss, never going to actually know what's going on.


03-16-2012 04:54 PM #33 Herd Burglar (Member)

Bottom line is Navuud deserves his money back. I don't even need to hear Brandon's side of the story, Navuud paid for something that was never given to him. It's also telling that Brandon wouldn't come here to defend himself, as owner of CPVLab (a subscription I just cancelled after reading this btw) he has A LOT to lose by a tainted reputation. The reason he's not on here defending himself is that he doesn't have a leg to stand on and he knows it.

FB doesn't change passwords of suspicious accounts, that just doesn't happen, everyone reading this who deals with multiple FB accounts knows they just disable them when anything is suspicious, end of story. The whole change PW thing makes the situation clear as day to me... Brandon is full of shit.


03-16-2012 05:29 PM #34 bbrock32 (Administrator)

Just to make this clear, we aren't friends or supporting any of the parties involved. Will try to get Brandon an account to solve this asap. Drama doesnt make money for anyone.


03-16-2012 07:32 PM #35 palmtree (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by Herd Burglar View Post

FB doesn't change passwords of suspicious accounts, that just doesn't happen, everyone reading this who deals with multiple FB accounts knows they just disable them when anything is suspicious, end of story. The whole change PW thing makes the situation clear as day to me... Brandon is full of shit.
I agree.

Even if that happened, he shouldn't have lost control of the email address the password recovery was tied to. They both should have had that on point, but that was primarily his responsibility IMO, cause it was still under his control.


03-16-2012 08:08 PM #36 heavyt (Senior Member)

Quote Originally Posted by bbrock32 View Post
Just to make this clear, we aren't friends or supporting any of the parties involved. Will try to get Brandon an account to solve this asap. Drama doesnt make money for anyone.
I would like to say this as well I don't want any ill will toward me but it seems like this is a pissing match that I don't want to get involved with it anymore. I'm stepping away. But me being a friend with brandon had no impact in what I did here. Yeah I deleted the other thread but I didn't know that there is a soft delete option, my bad sorry.

As of this point I'm hands off I don't wanna be involved in any way this is the last i'm posting in this thread.


03-16-2012 09:30 PM #37 403flux (Member)

Send Stewie after him.



But in all seriousness, OP should at least get his 5k back.

And why on earth would FB go through the trouble to change the password? They can lock you out with a click of a mouse.


03-16-2012 09:44 PM #38 ibanez (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by 403flux View Post
Send Stewie after him.



But in all seriousness, OP should at least get his 5k back.

And why on earth would FB go through the trouble to change the password? They can lock you out with a click of a mouse.

Yeh Stewie doesnt joke around with anyone:


03-16-2012 10:43 PM #39 groomez (Veteran Member)

What I don't get is that people are unsubscribing to CPVlab over a thread that they have no ties to at all. Over just pure speculation and a bunch of "he said she said". A lot of you dont know the whole story, so take a chill pill/laxative for a bit. Just got off the phone with Brandon and I'll just say to pop some more popcorn and reload your animated gifs.


03-16-2012 11:04 PM #40 palmtree (Member)

Brandon isn't the owner of CPV Lab. There is one sole owner and it is Robert. He had absolutely nothing to do with this. I understand the sentiment but it makes no sense to take it CPV Lab.


03-16-2012 11:07 PM #41 brandon_ (Member)
This is Brandon Clark, CPVlab

I’m a little disappointed that so many people on this forum (many that I’ve actually worked with) would be so quick to jump to conclusions and piggy back on an attack that is a total lie. Most everyone here should be familiar enough with this space, fb, and how accounts work – I shouldn’t even have to jump in to explain the details.

That being said, I have and will continue to do business with many of you, so I would hate to only have one side of a story out there for people to judge. The attacks also involve my company and my business partner, so now that the work week has ended and I’ve had a chance to read the entire thread, I’d be happy to jump in and say a few things to clear things up.

1. Here’s the situation, plain and simple: An inexperienced kid locks himself out of a facebook account he was already using without issue, and wants me to clean up his mess. I might have actually helped him out if he hadn’t attempted to completely drag my name through the mud in an industry where most business is conducted through word of mouth and referrals. It’s a little hard to want to continue to work with someone who does a google search for one of the most common names in America and posts the criminal record of a guy that’s 3 inches shorter and 100 pounds lighter than I am.
(It’s also kind of funny that he changes his own mind about what happened with the wind. One minute I’m a scammer, the next minute while he’s blasting me online he’s texting me trying to meet at adtech to do more business. A few minutes later, I’m a scammer again? Maybe he should make up his mind before getting himself locked out of his accounts for using the SAME IP for more than 1 account that was previously banned and blaming me) I have screenshots of texts from Shaun, admitting it’s his bad that I’ve sent to the forum admins. I also attached it to the post, time stamps and all. How big of a scam could this be, if he's apologizing for it?


2. I know many of you. I make regular appearances at every conference from Adtech NY, SF, London… to ASW and ASE to leadscon etc etc etc. I have long standing relationships and friendships with so many advertisers and traffic sources, why would I risk any of that for almost nothing?


3. Not many people that run a B2B company with a steady cash flow would jeopardize any of that (or have the need to) for $8K

4. I also have steady access to facebook accounts , and an even more steady demand to buy them—I’m pretty sure there is no need to try to “steal” an account from anyone.


5. Basically, this isn't any different than if Shaun were to have bought my iphone off of me, broke the screen because he threw the phone at the wall, and then asked me for a refund.


Now you have the facts and you can make a decision for yourself. If you know me or you’ve worked with me, then I’m sure this wasn’t even needed. But I hope it helps for others who were asking for an explanation.

Last thing, a few people suggested a refund. If I cannot deliver something that’s promised, I am the first person to refund a prepay. Again, most of the work I do is with prepaying customers—not something I am prepared to risk to scam someone out of one account.

We all know there is a risk associated with running traffic on facebook. I’m sorry that this kid’s account was slapped, but that isn’t because of anything I did. I may have even been open to coming up with a solution to help him out somehow – but all that went out the window when I heard about the lies being spread.


03-17-2012 12:56 AM #42 navuud (Member)

Great job spinning the whole situation Brandon, can't say I would expect you to tell the truth. I'm sure the people here can judge for themselves.

(It’s also kind of funny that he changes his own mind about what happened with the wind. One minute I’m a scammer, the next minute while he’s blasting me online he’s texting me trying to meet at adtech to do more business. A few minutes later, I’m a scammer again? Maybe he should make up his mind before getting himself locked out of his accounts for using the SAME IP for more than 1 account that was previously banned and blaming me) I have screenshots of texts from Shaun, admitting it’s his bad that I’ve sent to the forum admins. I also attached it to the post, time stamps and all. How big of a scam could this be, if he's apologizing for it?
1. Let me first address the text you put up:

I apologized for the contents of the other thread (which had FB info, etc.) because I don't want to engage in any back and forth, physical confrontation that you implied you were seeking when you sent those threats. I love the way you spin it such that others think that I'm apologizing for you scamming me. No, I don't apologize for that. I was going to leave it at this thread and cut my losses, but I don't apologize for you scamming me.

As far as the "I'll hit ya up at ad tech" is mentioned, I was simply offering an exchange of peace to meet and talk with you, like you did a day earlier (pic below) in your efforts to try to calm me down. I was doing the same. That doesn't mean I'm trying to do business with you (LOL, is anyone dumb enough to believe this).



2. Let me address how/why the account was locked.

1. Here’s the situation, plain and simple: An inexperienced kid locks himself out of a facebook account he was already using without issue, and wants me to clean up his mess. I might have actually helped him out if he hadn’t attempted to completely drag my name through the mud in an industry where most business is conducted through word of mouth and referrals. It’s a little hard to want to continue to work with someone who does a google search for one of the most common names in America and posts the criminal record of a guy that’s 3 inches shorter and 100 pounds lighter than I am.
So wait, you're saying the reason why the account was lost is because it was locked? Then why'd you forward me a fake e-mail trying to explain why the password was changed? That's because you changed the password and tried convincing me (do you really think anyone is this dumb?) that FB changed the PW? All the e-mails are logged brother, and Mr. Green even posted what you told him with the e-mail.

Your E-mail Editing Mistake:

Surely you didn't see your mistake and I didn't mention this before, but I'll pull the card now. You sent two e-mails to me (as Mr Green has also posted). The e-mail by Nealy Whisler, which is supposed to remain the same if you're quoting it, is different?

hosting
IP
Did you forget to edit it the second time you sent it?

Reason why the account was locked:

After exchanging texts/calls with you and it was clear that you weren't going to give me the account back, or the equivalent in money, I decided to lock the account to render it useless for you (as I've stated multiple times in this thread). I wasn't going to let you get away with my money + a useable $5k limit account.

(You can lock accounts with old passwords. FB then requires you to submit identification to match the name/business name on file)

Fact of the matter is this:
I lost control of the account because you changed the password, not because it was locked. It was locked after I had lost all hope of getting the account back from you.

3. Bumping account vs. Giving a new account

4. I also have steady access to facebook accounts , and an even more steady demand to buy them—I’m pretty sure there is no need to try to “steal” an account from anyone.
If you have such a steady access to FB accounts, why did it take you 2-3 weeks after I sent my payment for a $5k account for you to respond by offering a bump to the account limit? Couldn't you have just given me a $5k in February?

I don't know for sure if you have multiple accounts on a daily basis, but if you're willing to scam me for a $5k, I highly doubt you have a steady access to multiple accounts nowadays.

4. Your reputation

Your reputation, but moreso your position as a lead member at CPVlab was the reason why I trusted you. Clearly I was wrong.

Anyone with doubts about my story should ask themselves if Facebook would ever change anyone's password without their consent. No. They would suspend the account.


Also, Brandon mentioned on the phone an hour ago that he's lost 1400 subscribers to CPVlab because of this thread? Exaggerated a bit, Brandon?

In any case, I wanted to clarify to the users here that CPVlab didn't affect/scam me. Brandon Clark, a person who works for CPVlab, did.
I haven't accused CPVlab of anything. Take with that what you will.

In any case, my $7.5k is gone not because of any actions by Facebook, but because Brandon wanted the account back to resell it to make more money.


03-17-2012 01:45 AM #43 ibanez (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by navuud View Post

Your E-mail Editing Mistake:

Surely you didn't see your mistake and I didn't mention this before, but I'll pull the card now. You sent two e-mails to me (as Mr Green has also posted). The e-mail by Nealy Whisler, which is supposed to remain the same if you're quoting it, is different?
Interesting...


03-17-2012 01:47 AM #44 richardj (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by ibanez View Post
Interesting...

hahahahahahahahhahah!


03-17-2012 01:52 AM #45 boink (Member)

Nice catch ibanez! Bahahaahaha


03-17-2012 02:00 AM #46 richardj (Member)

I'm not one for "censorship" but this thread is getting ugly and I don't feel like there's anything that can be resolved here by fighting out a private conflict in a public domain. Brandon has had his say, and I'm glad he has because it has really brought the 2nd side to this story.

It's an unfortunate circumstance for both parties, but can we please nip this in the bud??? Aside from its damaging content, this thread is really distracting!


03-17-2012 02:07 AM #47 ibanez (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by richardj View Post
I'm not one for "censorship" but this thread is getting ugly and I don't feel like there's anything that can be resolved here by fighting out a private conflict in a public domain. Brandon has had his say, and I'm glad he has because it has really brought the 2nd side to this story.

It's an unfortunate circumstance for both parties, but can we please nip this in the bud??? Aside from its damaging content, this thread is really distracting!
I think this thread should be up for as long as he has not refunded the money to navuud. Emails and names dont change themselves as far as I know. If you just lost $7.5k to a guy over the internet, would you want to get it back? I don't see how and why both sides are unfortunate? One side just lost $7.5k, what did other side lost? This thread should stay there as a warning to future customers, if the reality is what we can see in the last few posts. If this thread is distracting to you, then there are parental control tools for you to help controlling the urge to refresh it :P


03-17-2012 02:12 AM #48 richardj (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by ibanez View Post
I think this thread should be up for as long as he has not refunded the money to navuud. Emails and names dont change themselves as far as I know. If you just lost $7.5k to a guy over the internet, would you want to get it back? I don't see how and why both sides are unfortunate? One side just lost $7.5k, what did other side lost? This thread should stay there as a warning to future customers, if the reality is what we can see in the last few posts. If this thread is distracting to you, then there are parental control tools for you to help controlling the urge to refresh it :P
Ha! I take your point, ibanez, but how are we to really know what is true and false in all this - considering the evidence in this thread can and possibly has been edited???


03-17-2012 02:18 AM #49 Hannah (Member)

Frankly, Brandon's "defense" was basically telling people that he was telling the truth combined with an iphone screenshot where the guy obviously apologized for the personal attacks but nothing else.

He didn't address what many people have brought up: Facebook simply disable your account if they want to ban you. I have never had anything to do with a lost password happen EVER in the 10 or so accounts I've lost, and I've never heard of it happening to anyone else either.

I've never had dealings with either person involved in this conflict, but I must say the OP is looking like he definitely has a stronger case here.


03-17-2012 02:39 AM #50 navuud (Member)

And now Brandon said he wants to sue me for costing CPVlab their subscribers because of this thread. Can someone tell me where I went wrong by exposing a scammer? Completely ridiculous.


03-17-2012 02:44 AM #51 corp (Member)

This thread is such a fucking mess. Here's timeline of what Navuud claims to have taken place.

1. Navuud purchased a 2.5k account from Brandon and all was good.

2. Then, Navuud prepaid him 5k for another account. Brandon stalled for 2 weeks and couldn't deliver.

3. Brandon promises to bump the 2.5k account to 10k in exchange for not delivering the 5k account, so Navuud gives him the login details.

4. Brandon successfully gets it bumped to 5k (not the 10k he promised). Navuud attempts to login on the 13th and sees the password has been changed.

5. Brandon doesn't admit to changing the password, instead he forwards Navuud a forged email (which is proven above) from an FB Rep saying they changed the password because he accessed the account from multiple ip addresses.

6. Navuud realizes Brandon has taken back the account and enters the old password numerous times to lock Brandon out.

Notice that Brandon didn't bother to dispute any of these points.


03-17-2012 04:18 AM #52 inversion (Member)

Brandon's post, in short, says:

"He's a noob. I'm legit. So, trust me."

It doesn't make Brandon wrong. It just doesn't clear anything up.


03-17-2012 04:28 AM #53 403flux (Member)

LOL @ Going to court over this. What do you plan on telling the judge? This guy defiled your company's name because he accused you of not delivering a product that you shouldn't have been selling in the first place?

You guys are gonna bring unwanted attention to FB accounts being sold on the secondary market and ruin the party for everyone. Then you can both have fun with FB's lawyers for violating their TOS.


03-17-2012 05:39 AM #54 lng (Member)

OP case is defiantly stronger after Brandon's response.


Refund money or deliver 10k account. Lock/close thread.
Done


03-17-2012 06:49 AM #55 joejoechen (Member)

i'm eager to see Brandon explains the forged / edited email... If this is the case, and if it's true, he doesn't has to explain for anything else, 1 is enough


03-17-2012 01:29 PM #56 ibanez (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by 403flux View Post
LOL @ Going to court over this. What do you plan on telling the judge? This guy defiled your company's name because he accused you of not delivering a product that you shouldn't have been selling in the first place?

You guys are gonna bring unwanted attention to FB accounts being sold on the secondary market and ruin the party for everyone. Then you can both have fun with FB's lawyers for violating their TOS.
Lets not forget forging emails from companies is illegal? Especially forging FB emails, interesting what would the real Nealey say.


03-17-2012 08:11 PM #57 navuud (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by 403flux View Post
LOL @ Going to court over this. What do you plan on telling the judge? This guy defiled your company's name because he accused you of not delivering a product that you shouldn't have been selling in the first place?

You guys are gonna bring unwanted attention to FB accounts being sold on the secondary market and ruin the party for everyone. Then you can both have fun with FB's lawyers for violating their TOS.
Right, this isn't worth it for any of us. I've accepted my loss and moved on.


03-17-2012 11:42 PM #58 Mr Green (Administrator)

This thread is now closed.


Home > Facebook & Instagram > Account Issues and Questions