Home > Push Traffic >

Follow-Along PUSH Campaign(Mob, PropellerAds & ClickDealer) (16)

10-18-2019 03:34 PM #1 amomaxia (Member)

Good luck!
Interested to see the results.
These LPs seem more aggro than what propeller allows (use of logos), were you able to pass propeller?

10-18-2019 03:59 PM #2 dollar (Senior Member)

Yes, Now approved

10-19-2019 01:37 AM #3 dollar (Senior Member)

AM said that the offer forbids US Ip access because the VPN is locked, so add 75428offer to the volume.

10-19-2019 12:20 PM #4 dollar (Senior Member)

Continue to add the zoneid that has not been converted before the current time and the click rate is lower than the average to the blacklist.

10-20-2019 02:12 PM #5 afkuni (Member)

Great follow-along, thanks and good luck!

I'm a total newbie but could try to suggest:
* You could try running separate campaigns for mobile and web - the bids usually differ
* Do you see any patterns when browsing all variables (like OS, OS version, browser, etc)?

10-20-2019 09:20 PM #6 matuloo (Legendary Moderator)

Looks like one of the offers is performing better, based on todays stats, so I would focus on that one.

At this point, since you have an offer that's converting pretty good and you're not that far from breakeven, it's all about working on the ADs and tweaking the LPs, along with blocking the non performing placements. Finding better, more aggressive landers can help you a lot too.

What afkuni posted above is also solid advice, mobile VS desktop both convert differently and the bids are different too, have you tried breaking them up or are you targeting both in the same campaign? Try to look deeper at the data and look for traffic segments that perform the best ... maybe some device/browser combination? The you could focus on that.

I would also try to find more offers from different networks and don't forget there are more traffic sources too, you could test some others as well.

Not a bad start at all!

10-21-2019 06:38 AM #7 dollar (Senior Member)

Quote Originally Posted by afkuni View Post
Great follow-along, thanks and good luck!

I'm a total newbie but could try to suggest:
* You could try running separate campaigns for mobile and web - the bids usually differ
* Do you see any patterns when browsing all variables (like OS, OS version, browser, etc)?
Thanks for your suggest, Today I limit some OS & OS versions that don't perform well

10-21-2019 06:56 AM #8 dollar (Senior Member)

Quote Originally Posted by matuloo View Post
I would also try to find more offers from different networks and don't forget there are more traffic sources too, you could test some others as well.
Since I have less investment now, I focus on the SOI offer for sweetstakes. Is there any recommended affiliate networks?

10-21-2019 09:33 AM #9 matuloo (Legendary Moderator)

Quote Originally Posted by dollar View Post
Since I have less investment now, I focus on the SOI offer for sweetstakes. Is there any recommended affiliate networks?
Gotzha always has some good sweep offers, try them. Advidi is another proven one to go with.

10-22-2019 02:25 AM #10 dollar (Senior Member)

I think this is a good start, this is the data of October 20th.
Attachment 22368

And This is today's data:
Attachment 22369

But the question now is how can I improve my ROI?
I added the poorly-performing Zoneid to the blacklist and kept the good OS versions. Do each of the influencing factors do A/B test? For example 3G/WI-FI?

10-22-2019 11:52 AM #11 matuloo (Legendary Moderator)

Quote Originally Posted by dollar View Post
I think this is a good start, this is the data of October 20th.
Attachment 22368

And This is today's data:
Attachment 22369

But the question now is how can I improve my ROI?
I added the poorly-performing Zoneid to the blacklist and kept the good OS versions. Do each of the influencing factors do A/B test? For example 3G/WI-FI?
Can you please upload the screens to a service like imgur.com and then post the "sahre url" here? The vbulletin attachment function is buggy and the screens don't load for me

3G vs WIFI can really perform very differently and the bids for each are often quite different too. So in an ideal case, you should target them separately. Take a look at your data to see if it makes sense.

Not sure about how many ADs and LPs you tried by now, the right AD can really change a lot and so does the LP. You can obviously take the route of narrowing down the best performing type of traffic and buy just that. The only problem here is that the more granular you go, the lower the available volume will be. So your ultimate goal should be to put together a funnel that works well with as many targets as possible. That's why I'm suggesting to focus on the ADs and LPs more.

10-23-2019 06:25 AM #12 dollar (Senior Member)

Sunday‘s Data：
https://imgur.com/FHKIySU
Monday’s Data:
https://imgur.com/Eapjp4q

Tuesday's Data:
https://imgur.com/eo4X7wg

Yesterday, The ROI struggles below the balance point

10-23-2019 06:29 AM #13 dollar (Senior Member)

Quote Originally Posted by matuloo View Post
Not sure about how many ADs and LPs you tried by now, the right AD can really change a lot and so does the LP. You can obviously take the route of narrowing down the best performing type of traffic and buy just that. The only problem here is that the more granular you go, the lower the available volume will be. So your ultimate goal should be to put together a funnel that works well with as many targets as possible. That's why I'm suggesting to focus on the ADs and LPs more.
I used 6 Ads & 7 Lander, There are now 2 Lander and 3 Ads

10-31-2019 01:14 PM #14 dollar (Senior Member)

https://imgur.com/kcXZrH4
October 27:
Click: 751
Conversions: 45
Spent: $67.27
Revenue: $118.50
ROI: 76.15%

https://imgur.com/akLWNW4
October 28:
Click: 466
Conversions: 24
Spent: $41.81
Revenue: $67.66
ROI: 61.83%

https://imgur.com/o53tXEF
October 29
Click: 428
Conversions: 25
Spent: $38.31
Revenue: $69.22
ROI: 80.7%

https://imgur.com/9wK4jCH
October 30
Click: 467
Conversions: 26
Spent: $41.77
Revenue: $71.80
ROI: 71.89%

11-01-2019 02:49 AM #15 sushiparlour (Member)

Thats pretty good results, seem like you just need to figure out how to scale it. My 2c on scaling is that from what I've experience if you are running US then due to the volume of traffic available you might see significantly different results from 1 traffic source to another.

12-19-2019 12:17 AM #16 octapad (Member)

Do you think it matters that you used a bigger image as well as the icon?
I heard that those bigger images are totally ineffective as nobody actually sees them in their notification.. Could you have boosted your ROI% if you removed them because the ad might've performed better/looked tighter? Just a thought.

Home > Push Traffic >