Home > Paid Traffic Sources > Facebook & Instagram

very low ROI on whitehat campaigns (12)


09-19-2014 06:46 AM #1 12as26 (Member)
very low ROI on whitehat campaigns

recently i have started running some stuff on mobile and desktop newsfeed, that is not cloaked, in verticals such as careers, auto, gaming etc.

they are all green or yellow myWOT. i optimize images/copy etc pretty actively and yet can't cross then 10-20% ROI mark. this is on decent spend amounts mid four figures.

is this par for the course for FB if you are running whitehat stuff. i wouldnt know to be honest.


09-19-2014 08:30 AM #2 waylander (Member)

No mate. I guess it depends on the vertical, but that's not my experience.


09-19-2014 08:39 AM #3 nickster (Member)

Are you direct linking or using a LP?

If its a LP then just split test the hell out of it, try different angles etc. Breaking even on an offer early on, especially a white hat one, is a really good sign!


09-19-2014 04:32 PM #4 bbrock32 (Administrator)

No, you can definitively have a higher ROI on whitehat campaigns.

Actually the fact that you are already profitable is a great sign.

Keep playing with the ads and landers and you will soon have triple digit ROI.


09-20-2014 11:25 AM #5 cmdeal (Veteran Member)

Quote Originally Posted by 12as26 View Post
recently i have started running some stuff on mobile and desktop newsfeed, that is not cloaked, in verticals such as careers, auto, gaming etc.

they are all green or yellow myWOT. i optimize images/copy etc pretty actively and yet can't cross then 10-20% ROI mark. this is on decent spend amounts mid four figures.

is this par for the course for FB if you are running whitehat stuff. i wouldnt know to be honest.
Okay, let's run the numbers here ...

  1. You say mid-four figures, so let's assume about $5000 spend a day.
  2. You say it is running at 10-20% ROI, so let's assume at ~15%, so about $750 profit per day.
  3. You say it is pure white hat, so let's assume that this is a more or less sustainable activity that you can run safely for a year (so 365 days) or more.

That is now $273,750 profit a year on a total revenue base of $2,098,750.

As problems go, these are nice problems to have.

I'd much rather have this problem than having to worry about a 250% ROI black hat campaign on $1000 of spend that can get pulled away at any time.


09-20-2014 01:11 PM #6 radiosurf (Member)

Unless, of course, that four figures includes the decimal point

Nice post... that makes a good argument for low ROI campaigns having value.


09-20-2014 02:42 PM #7 nickster (Member)

Quote Originally Posted by radiosurf View Post
Unless, of course, that four figures includes the decimal point

Nice post... that makes a good argument for low ROI campaigns having value.
They have more than value, they are GOLD if they are scalable.


10-18-2014 04:07 PM #8 johnaff (AMC Alumnus)

usually theres always a 'big fix' that can double the ROI of any campaign. Whether its a new lander, new type of lander, different ad copy, more refined targeting, different ad unit, particular exclusions, different higher converting offer, etc., its always important to be exploring whats 'the doubler'.

@CMdeal, the math you point out is nice, but from my experience those numbers dont work out on facebook...audiences get burned through quickly and ROI fluctuates a lot, and its more of a 'burst campaign' approach in my experience. Get something working, optimize, expand the f out of the audience, and grab as much cash as possible, until you burn out the angle, then create some new angles and try it again.


10-23-2014 02:30 AM #9 jason a (Senior Member)

I wish I could find consistent FB compliant camps that were getting me 10 percent ROI. This coming from a guy who gets inconstant blackhat ROI at 100+ percent.


10-24-2014 10:14 AM #10 tiger_haha (Member)

it must be have a zone to optimize, at the first, the cost is relatively high, after running for a period of time, the ROI will be higher.


10-24-2014 10:44 AM #11 cmdeal (Veteran Member)

Quote Originally Posted by johnaff View Post
@CMdeal, the math you point out is nice, but from my experience those numbers dont work out on facebook...audiences get burned through quickly and ROI fluctuates a lot, and its more of a 'burst campaign' approach in my experience. Get something working, optimize, expand the f out of the audience, and grab as much cash as possible, until you burn out the angle, then create some new angles and try it again.
This may be the case for niche black hat campaigns, but this is definitely not the case for large audience, highly scalable white hat campaigns on FB.


10-29-2014 09:52 PM #12 johna5150 (Senior Member)

The other thing to keep in mind about numbers like these are they are fantastic if you are also acquiring a customer or an email address you can market to in the future...all follow up sales are virtually pure profit, and you can use that email list to direct people to CPA offers, relevant pages with Adsense, etc. And even if Facebook gets huffy and shuts you down, you will have built an asset the will continue to give you money long after your initial campaigns are over...


Home > Paid Traffic Sources > Facebook & Instagram